National Consumer News

Should you get the flu shot?


Debbie Lord

Cox Media Group National Content Desk

We hear the recommendations around this time every year – it’s flu season and we should get a vaccination, we’re told.

With a few exceptions,  everyone 6 months old and older should get an annual flu vaccination, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Shots are offered at work, at pharmacies and even at drive-thru events. But, if you are a healthy adult, do you need to get the shot?

What about your children? Should they get shots?

Vaccine manufacturers are on track to make as many as 176 million doses of flu vaccine for the 2016-17 flu season,according to the CDC. Enough for Americans who want to get the shot during an average flu season (during the 2014-15 season,  148.1 million Americans were vaccinated).

Included in that number, are 14 million doses of a flu vaccine delivered via nasal spray. The CDC announced recently that it is not recommending doctors give the nasal spray version – which is primarily to given to children – because studies have shown a decline in effectiveness.

Some recent studies are questioning the need for an annual flu vaccination delivered by any means.

A study headed by Dr. Edward Belongia of the Marshfield (Wisconsin) Clinic Research Foundation, reported that children who had been vaccinated annually for at least five years were more likely to contract the flu than children who were vaccinated only in the flu season in which the study was conducted.

“The vaccine was significantly more effective … if they had not been vaccinated in the previous five years,” Belongia, an epidemiologist, said in an interview with

Here’s a look at what researchers are finding.

How do vaccines work?

Vaccines work to spur your body to create antibodies to fight disease. In the case of influenza, the CDC explains the flu vaccine this way:

“Flu vaccines cause antibodies to develop in the body about two weeks after vaccination. These antibodies provide protection against infection with the viruses that are in the vaccine. The seasonal flu vaccine protects against the influenza viruses that research indicates will be most common during the upcoming season.

“Traditional flu vaccines (called “trivalent” vaccines) are made to protect against three flu viruses; an influenza A (H1N1) virus, an influenza A (H3N2) virus, and an influenza B virus. There are also flu vaccines made to protect against four flu viruses (called “quadrivalent” vaccines). These vaccines protect against the same viruses as the trivalent vaccine and an additional B virus.”

How would having a vaccination each year cause the next year’s vaccine to be less effective?

How yearly vaccines can cause subsequent vaccines to be less effective involves the components that make up the shot, according to the story.

Scientists believe that when a component of the influenza vaccine does not change from year to year, the antibodies made from the vaccine from year one can neutralize some of the antibodies spurred by the shot in subsequent years.

That neutralization of subsequent antibodies happens before the body can trigger a full immune response to the vaccine. The immune response takes about two weeks to fully develop.

If you know that getting the vaccine in subsequent  years can make it less effective, why not skip it?

You don’t want to skip the vaccine because each year’s shot provides protection against up to three or four types of the virus. Getting any protection against the flu is a good thing.

Each year, vaccine manufacturers include protection in the vaccines for the strains of virus that they believe are most likely to be active that year.

If you do get a component that you got last year and it blocks some effectiveness of the current vaccine, you are still better off by having the protection of the other components.

Vaccine researchers stress they are not suggesting that people stop getting the yearly vaccine – at least not any time soon. They are continuing to evaluate the need for yearly vaccinations, according to Dr. Danuta Skowronski, a flu expert at British Columbia’s Center for Disease Control in Vancouver.

“For me,  anyway, these repeat vaccine effects are among the most important developments in influenza vaccinology of the past decade,” Skowronski told

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter